Gangsta Lasers Academy
08 · Published8 min read

How many sessions? An honest range instead of a promise — the Kirby-Desai scale at consultation

Six questions, one total and the reason that with today’s lasers the total usually comes out too high. How to turn the score into an honest range, what to tell the client, when to revise the range, and why permanent make-up needs its own assessment.

Written by Justyna Grondke-Trąbska
Co-founder of Gangsta Lasers · leads the whole programme

In short

  • One number said at consultation stays in the client’s memory for a whole year. We give a range, say what it depends on and agree when we will review it.
  • In the paper that introduced the Kirby-Desai scale (100 patients, 2004–2008), the mean score was 9.87 points and the mean number of treatments 9.91.
  • Newer, small studies show that with today’s lasers the scale usually predicts more sessions than were needed. We treat the total as the top of the range, not a forecast.
  • In a group of 116 people treated with a picosecond laser, ink density and location lengthened the series most — not phototype or tattoo size.
  • The scale was never tested on permanent make-up. For brows and eyeliner we base the range on the pigment assessment, the history of corrections and a test patch.
  • After the third session we compare photographs and give an updated range — at a moment the client has known about since her first visit.

The question asked at every consultation

“How many sessions will it take?” The question comes up at every consultation, usually before you have had a chance to look at the pigment in good light. The easiest answer is a single number, preferably a small one, because the client is hoping for good news. And that number is the one she remembers for a whole year.

If you say “five” and the series ends at the ninth session, the client will not remember a good result. She will remember hearing “just one more” four times. The problem was not the laser; it was the promise.

That is why we do not give a single number at the first visit, but a range: we say what it depends on and agree when we will narrow it. Below we show how to work it out so that it can be defended — with the Kirby-Desai scale in hand, but without blind faith in its result.

The Kirby-Desai scale in brief

In the week 5 note we set out the six categories of the Kirby-Desai scale: skin type, location, colours, amount of ink, scarring and tissue change, and layering, for example after a cover-up. Each category gets points, and the total is meant to match the approximate number of sessions needed to remove the tattoo. The lowest possible total is 4 points, the highest 26.

The scale was built from the records of 100 patients at one clinic in Beverly Hills, treated between 2004 and 2008 with Q-switched lasers. The authors assumed 6–8 weeks between sessions. Every patient reached complete removal. The mean score was 9.87 points and the mean number of treatments 9.91 — from 3 to 20. Points and number of sessions were strongly related (r = 0.757).[1]

The authors added an important caveat: a tattoo scoring more than 15 points may be difficult to remove and should be assessed by a physician.[1] It is a signal that planning such a series goes beyond a standard consultation.

Why the total comes out too high today

The scale is seventeen years old, and devices and working techniques have changed noticeably since. Newer papers point the same way: with today’s lasers, the total usually predicts more sessions than were actually needed.

Egozi and Toledano (2024) compared the scale’s predictions with the course of removal in 11 people treated with a Q-switched Nd:YAG laser. The scale predicted 9.9 sessions on average; 5.09 were done on average.[3] Aurangabadkar and colleagues (2019), working with 22 people with amateur single-colour tattoos and a different technique within each session, needed 1 to 4 sessions where the scale predicted 7 to 14.[4]

Menozzi-Smarrito and Pineau (2025) built their own model from 116 people with black tattoos treated with a 755 nm picosecond laser. They needed 6 sessions on average, from 2 to 20. Tested on 12 tattoos, the authors’ model was off by about 2.2 sessions on average and the Kirby-Desai scale by about 3.7 (measured as RMSE).[2]

To be fair: these are small groups, different devices and protocols, and one author of the 2024 paper works for the laser’s manufacturer. These studies do not give a new number. They show that the total is a sensible upper limit of expectations, not a forecast to the session.

The Kirby-Desai scale: accurate in 2009, too high today

Data from the chart
2009 · predicted by the scale (mean score)9.87 sess.
2009 · done on average9.91 sess.
2024 · predicted by the scale9.9 sess.
2024 · done on average5.09 sess.
2009: 100 patients, Q-switched lasers (Kirby and colleagues). 2024: 11 people, Q-switched Nd:YAG laser (Egozi and Toledano; one author works for the laser’s manufacturer). A small group — a direction, not a new norm.

What we see at Gangsta Lasers

Working with Gangsta Lasers technology, we see the same direction in the clinic: the series usually ends earlier than the total suggests. Even so, we do not promise a shorter series at consultation. We treat the total as the upper end of the range, set the lower end after assessing the pigment, ink density and location, and check the whole plan after the third session. It is what we teach at the Academy: assessment first, then the range, then the word given to the client.

What really lengthens a series

More interesting than the miss itself is which features actually mattered in Menozzi-Smarrito and Pineau’s work. Ink density came first: low-density tattoos needed about 3.2 sessions on average, high-density tattoos about 9.[2]

Location counted too. Removal was shortest on the upper trunk — 4.3 sessions on average — and longest on the hand and fingers: 7.8. The technique of the tattoo also mattered (dots 4.4 sessions on average, lines 6.9), as did the age of the tattoo itself.[2]

It may come as a surprise what had no significant effect in this group: skin type, tattoo size and the client’s age. Skin type still decides safety and the choice of wavelength, as we wrote in week 1 — in this group it simply did not decide the length of the series.

What lengthened the series: mean number of sessions

Data from the chart
Low-density ink3.2 sess.
High-density ink9 sess.
Upper trunk4.3 sess.
Hand and fingers7.8 sess.
Technique: dots4.4 sess.
Technique: lines6.9 sess.
116 people, black tattoos, 755 nm picosecond laser (Menozzi-Smarrito and Pineau, 2025). Skin type, tattoo size and the client’s age had no significant effect in this group.

Permanent make-up is a different story

The Kirby-Desai scale was neither designed nor tested on permanent make-up — the paper that describes it does not mention it at all. Brows, eyeliner and lips have different pigments, a smaller surface and often many earlier corrections. Scoring built for artistic tattoos does not carry over to them directly.

For brow and eyeliner make-up we have other numbers: in a review of 76 cases (Kream and colleagues, 2023), 2.8 sessions were needed on average, from 1 to 12.[5] That spread says more than the average. As we showed in week 7, revealed warm shades, pigments that may darken and earlier camouflage can lengthen a series while it is under way.

With permanent make-up, then, we base the range on the pigment assessment, the history of corrections and the result of a test patch, which we described in week 3 — not on a points total. The scale can serve as a list of consultation questions, but not as a calculator.

From points to a range

With a tattoo we reach the range in five steps, always in the same order. That way two people in one clinic will give the same client a similar range, and each one can later be reconstructed from the record.

From points to a range: five steps at consultation

  1. ScoreThe six categories of the scale, each recorded separately in the client’s record.
  2. Upper limitThe total is the top of the range with today’s device, not a forecast.
  3. Lower limitLower it for sparse ink and a favourable location, for example the trunk rather than the hand.
  4. Above 15 pointsA physician’s assessment first, the conversation about a range after.
  5. Record and bookThe range, the 6–8 week interval and the date of the review after the third session.
With permanent make-up the scale is only a list of questions — base the range on the pigment assessment and a test patch.

An illustrative example: a professional black tattoo on the shoulder blade, skin type II, a moderate amount of ink, no scarring and no layers. On the scale that is 2 + 2 + 1 + 3 + 0 + 0, or 8 points. We do not promise eight sessions. We say we estimate five to eight, and that after the third session we will be more precise.

By comparison, a coloured tattoo on the hand, done as a cover-up over an old design, quickly passes 15 points. Then the first step is not a range but a physician’s assessment, and an honest conversation about whether complete removal is a realistic goal or whether lightening for a new design is the better plan.

A sentence for the client

A range only makes sense if the client hears it exactly as you write it in the record. That is why we use one sentence at every consultation:

I estimate X to Y sessions, every 6–8 weeks. After the third session I will tell you more precisely, because every skin and every pigment responds differently.

That sentence gives a range, not a number. It says how the series spreads over time, so the client knows she is planning a year, not a month. And it announces a second conversation, so changing the range after the third session is keeping your word, not admitting a mistake. The 6–8 week interval is the practice used in the papers we rely on, not the result of a study comparing intervals.[1,6]

After the third session: the second conversation

After the third session, once the skin has healed, we compare the photographs from every visit, taken in the same light and framing, as described in week 4. Only then can you see how this particular pigment responds to this particular device in this particular skin.

The range then narrows or shifts. If the pigment is clearing faster, we say so gladly. If more slowly, we show the photographs, name the reason — ink density, location or a revealed shade, for example — and give the new range. The client hears it from us at the agreed moment, before she starts counting sessions herself.

If there is no change at all after three sessions, we go back to the week 5 checklist: expectations, interval, wavelength, technique, device and the client. The range is then the last thing to correct, not the first.

What goes in the record

In the client’s record

  • the scale result and the points in each category;
  • the range given at consultation and the interval between sessions;
  • the date of the review and the new range, if it changed;
  • photographs from every visit, in the same light and framing.

After a dozen or so series, your records begin to predict better than any scale, because they describe your device, technique and clients. The scale is a starting point, and your records let you give ever narrower ranges over time.

An honest range is not hedging. It is the only promise that can be kept — and it is what keeps the client with you until the last session.

Sources

  1. Kirby W, Desai A, Desai T, Kartono F, Patel G. The Kirby-Desai Scale: A Proposed Scale to Assess Tattoo-removal Treatments. J Clin Aesthet Dermatol. 2009;2(3):32–37.
  2. Menozzi-Smarrito C, Pineau N. A New Predictive Model for Tattoo Removal: Leveraging Patient and Tattoo Characteristics. J Cosmet Dermatol. 2025;24(7):e70186.
  3. Egozi E, Toledano O. A retrospective clinical evaluation of Q-switched Nd:YAG laser safety and efficacy for tattoo removal, with a new perspective on the Kirby-Desai scale. J Cosmet Dermatol. 2024;23(3):818–823.
  4. Aurangabadkar S, Shah S, Kulkarni D, Aurangabadkar M. A Prospective Open-labeled Study of Tattoo Removal with Q-Switched Nd:YAG Laser Utilizing the R0 Technique and Correlation with Kirby-Desai Scale. J Cutan Aesthet Surg. 2019;12(2):95–104.
  5. Kream E, Jairath N, Bajaj S, Orbuch D, Wang JV, Geronemus RG. Laser Removal of Eyeliner and Eyebrow Tattoos: Chart Review, Experiences, and Learnings. J Clin Aesthet Dermatol. 2023;16(11):47–49.
  6. Cannarozzo G, Nisticò SP, Zappia E, et al. Q-Switched 1064/532 nm Laser with Nanosecond Pulse in Tattoo Treatment: A Double-Center Retrospective Study. Life (Basel). 2021;11(7):699.

Subjects

  • how many tattoo removal sessions
  • Kirby-Desai scale
  • consultation before removal
  • number of laser sessions
  • series plan
  • permanent make-up removal